Apr 17, 2011

New Music: Isis - Live V

Album Score: 8.5/10
Note: “Live V” is a live recording of “Oceanic.” This review is mainly about how it compares to its parent album, not a critique of the material on “Oceanic” itself.

Music is meant to be listened to live. While studio production can add nuance and depth to a recording, a band that can captivate an audience with their music the old fashioned way is something special. Unfortunately, with today’s advanced technology, artists all too often rely on gimmicks and having infinite chances to “get it right.” Isis’ seminal album, “Oceanic,” was a terrific example of how production can be a positive influence on the finished product. The glimmering female vocals on “The Beginning and the End” were wrought with emotional tension; the soft sounds of wind and waves in “Weight” gave it a chilling atmosphere. But their effectiveness begs the question: what if these subtle additions were removed?